• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Humphrey Hawksley

Author, commentator and broadcaster

  • Home
  • About
  • Journalism
  • Books
  • Humphrey’s
    Diary
  • Blog
  • Contact
    & Photos
  • Rake Ozenna Thrillers
  • Future History
  • International Thrillers
  • Non-Fiction
  • All Books

Lenin and Mao – One day they’ll get it right

30th May 2006

CALCUTTA, May 2006

 The people of West Bengal have voted in the Communist Party for the seventh successive time. In its capital, Calcutta, a statue of Lenin dominates a main square and red flags of the hammer and sickle fly everywhere. So why have Indians not debunked communism?

Subodh Roy, I see when he stands up to greet me, is a small yet powerful figure. He holds the edge of his newspaper down on the desk top, to stop the overhead ceiling fan blowing it about.

At 88, his voice is soft, difficult to hear above the noise of traffic horns and bustle from the poor Muslim neighbourhood outside.

But his confidence is unwavering.

‘Stalin,’ I said. ‘Was he a good leader?’

‘Yes. Yes. Stalin was strong,’ he says, his eyes straight on me.

‘And Mao Tse-Tung of China?’

‘Yes, Mao. He was good. He fought for communism, too, in the Chinese way.’

‘But I thought communism had failed?’ I said.

‘No. No,’ replies Mr Roy. ‘We will get it right this time.’

We are in the headquarters of the Communist Party of West Bengal where the meeting room is adorned with portraits of Stalin, Marx, Engels and Lenin.

There is a bust of Mao and a painting of Vietnam’s Ho Chi Minh, with red banners of the hammer and sickle stretched across the walls.

The place has a spring in its step, because the chief minister, Buddhadeb Bhattacharya, huddled in a nearby room, is celebrating his Communist Party’s seventh consecutive election victory, with a vastly increased mandate. He is brimming with new ideas on how to re-apply communism to make it work and he is not looking West towards the World Bank or Wall Street for advice, but East towards China.

‘The main thing China has done,’ he says, ‘is to allow different types of ownership: state ownership, collective ownership – even private ownership and foreign investment. That’s what we’re planning.’

‘But you’re a democracy,’ I question. ‘China says it achieved its success precisely because it isn’t one.’

‘Yes,’ he smiles ruefully.

‘We know the one party-state won’t work here. The Chinese economy has an inner strength so they are bargaining from a position of strength. We are still begging.’

All around Calcutta huge billboards advertise designer clothes, mobile phones and dream homes. Down on the streets, though, nothing much seems to have changed. A textured blend of chaotic humanity still reigns. It is as if India – as a vast competing developing nation – is paying lip-service to China’s success, but deep down, it does not actually want it.

‘The thing about China,’ says an urbane middle-aged woman in one of Calcutta’s modern shopping malls, ‘is that the people have no human rights.’

‘Yes,’ adds a young man next to her. ‘We’re not ready to sacrifice human rights to get people out of poverty. Absolutely not.’

That is all very well coming from someone not in poverty, but outside Calcutta, I find two women, heaving sacks of rice along a village track. This is the India where 80% of people live on less than two dollars a day. China has got that down to less than half – meaning that millions and millions have clawed their way out.

To achieve anything like that, India will have to attract foreign money.

But, right now, foreign investors risk £35bn ($65 bn) a year in autocratic China but only £2.5bn ($4.5bn) in democratic India. Why?

You just have to look at the tangle of electrical cables clustered on the sides of buildings and huge signs asking people to report the theft of electricity.

Any multi-national company investing in India’s power industry would have to deal with the fact that a quarter of all India’s electricity is stolen. And no-one seems to be doing much about it.

So I ask the two women, who have put their rice down by a hut: ‘Would you be happy to forfeit your right to vote if it meant improving your living standards.’

‘Vote,’ they say. Villagers gather round, shaking their heads. ‘Vote,’ they all say.

‘Vote.’

‘If we choose the right people, then our lives will improve,’ says one.

‘Did you all support the Communist Party?’

‘Ninety per cent of it,’ says another. ‘They are very good.’

‘But then… ‘ I begin to challenge, and stopped, because India is not like China with its obsessive pursuit of wealth and the future.

Each of the villagers turns out to have an individual dream which they feel this society gives them the freedom to pursue – at least a bit.

One man sees himself as a poet. Another wants a breakthrough as a singer. And as for the Communist Party, well it has given them all small plots of land.

China’s boom has raised questions within the developing world as to whether human dignity should be measured by material wealth or freedom, and it is trying to prove that in the early stages you cannot have both That has led many Indians to question whether their own country has too much democracy.

Returning from the village, a demonstration blocks off one of Calcutta’s main intersections dominated as it happens by a statue of Lenin.

We divert down small roads, crammed with market stalls. Walking through the crowd, head high, eyes curious, arms swinging confidently and oozing self esteem, is a man without a stitch of clothing on. Those around – mothers, children, shoppers, traders – do not flinch.

In China – in fact, in most places in the world – he would be arrested. But this is India, where freedom and human dignity are measured in a different way.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Primary Sidebar

For enquiries and further information

To contact Humphrey:
[email protected]

Before sending your email address please read our GDPR Compliance Statement and Privacy Notice to reassure yourself that we are looking after your data responsibly.

More reports

Democracy fights back

In a business district a couple of miles from Vilnius’ Medieval Old Town, an office block sign lists … [Read More...]

If you want giant glaciers, wondrous wildlife and the adventure of a lifetime, Alaska is waiting for you

Riding in a high-speed catamaran along an Alaskan fjord, the captain asked: ‘See that glacier ahead? … [Read More...]

Asian countries must restrain hawkish AUKUS parties

Since leaving the European Union last year, the British government has decisively pursued two … [Read More...]

ANC Airport

Alaska’s growing global trade hub highlights booming US-Asian trade

For a few months last year, the prize for the busiest airport in the world slipped away from those … [Read More...]

Global rules against cyberattacks must be updated

The cyberattack that shut down an American East Coast pipeline underlines a global security … [Read More...]

From Our Own Correspondent

The Philippines — How China Plans to Win the Asia-Pacific

3rd March 2017

Taiwan-China – a Flashpoint Once More

19th February 2017

Living on America’s Border with Russia

28th August 2015

World Peace Begins in the Bedroom

5th June 2015

The curse of gold

30th May 2012

The supply chain children

30th January 2012

Experiments in aid

30th January 2011

Joining the club

30th July 2010

Banking nuclear fuel

26th January 2010

The ceremony of port

30th December 2009

Dancing with the devil

30th June 2009

The Contractor’s War

30th March 2009

Sharing your man for Jesus

30th March 2009

A million good workers needed

30th October 2008

Russia’s human weapon

30th September 2008

Cold War bunker

30th August 2008

Smoke-filled rooms and the law

30th June 2008

War scars, a handshake and a beacon

26th June 2008

Make knives not war

30th March 2008

Baghdad banking and real estate boom

30th January 2008

America is our ally

30th November 2007

Russia’s red line over Kosovo

30th October 2007

Big Brother is watching us all

30th September 2007

Small town with a big heart

30th June 2007

The democratic mission

30th May 2007

How Kosovo worked

30th January 2007

Hell escape

30th November 2006

Reporting from Israel

30th August 2006

Peace? With our politicians – never

26th June 2006

China in the backyard

30th April 2006

Reporting from Poland

26th February 2006

Addicted to oil

26th February 2006

The boy who lived on a garbage dump

30th December 2005

Republican missionaries in New Mexico

26th November 2005

The American dream

30th July 2005

Why did they fight?

30th April 2005

Haunted by the Ottomans

27th February 2005

Empires and abortion

30th December 2004

The young political elite

30th September 2004

Beer with the Hizbollah

30th July 2004

The patriot act

30th June 2004

An economist in Patagonia

27th April 2004

Someone else in her house

28th February 2004

Big threats, no health care

30th December 2003

Inside India’s nuclear program

30th November 2003

Suicide slum

30th September 2003

The politics of SARS

30th April 2003

The Christian mission

27th February 2003

Blood cocoa

30th May 2002

The war crime pen-pushers

30th January 2002

Triple border terror

30th January 2002

Europe’s apartheid

30th September 2001

The blonde and the dying

30th March 2001

Never to be freed

30th January 2000

One wrong turning

30th May 1999

Footer

Search site

Goldster

  • The Goldster Inside Story Podcast
  • Goldster Video Archive

Connect with Humphrey

  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Join Humphrey’s mailing list

Subscribe

Email Humphrey

For general enquiries and bookings for events:

[email protected] and [email protected]

Copyright © 2008–2023 Humphrey Hawksley · All rights reserved · Site Terms, Cookies and Privacy · GDPR Compliance Statement · Website by LiT Web Studio