• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Humphrey Hawksley

Author, commentator and broadcaster

  • Home
  • About
  • Journalism
  • Books
  • Humphrey’s
    Diary
  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • Contact
    & Photos
  • Rake Ozenna Thrillers
  • Future History
  • International Thrillers
  • Non-Fiction
  • All Books

Why did they fight?

30th April 2005

BEIRUT April 2005

Political tension has mounted in Lebanon since the killing in February of the former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri who did much to rebuild the country after its 15-year civil war. What is the risk of fresh conflict there?

Ali Aliwan, just turned 41, is a jovial man – red-faced, fingers stained with nicotine, a slight paunch. When I met him, his concentration was on a game of street draughts and he wasn’t shy with advice on his next move.

He was with half a dozen others, in the middle of the morning, board balanced on an upturned box, next to a wall still pockmarked with bullets from the civil war which ended 15 years ago.

They had all fought in it, and Ali led me across the road and up a mound, half grass, half debris.

‘This was the exact line between east and west Beirut. You had snipers everywhere and you couldn’t cross,’ he said, overlooking a parking lot where the sun in the light blue Beirut sky was catching the chrome of the Mercedes and BMWs parked there.

Ali had fought for a Muslim, pro-Palestinian militia, but he also referred to himself in outdated international language as being a leftist. And when asked about the risk of another civil war, he shook his head.

‘No,’ he said. ‘You see, we were funded by foreign powers and that’s not happening this time.’

In a way, the civil war mirrored the Cold War in that the US supported one side and the Soviet Union another.

Now Lebanon once again finds itself caught directly in the crossfire of a new global conflict, a tiny country with fragile loyalties buffeted between America and Syria, one of Washington’s more recent enemies.

The political platforms – as seen from outside – depend on whether you are pro- or anti-Syrian.

The pros represent Islamic authoritarianism, the antis the democratic West. This is why anti-Syrian demonstrations are hailed in Washington as part of a wave of democracy sweeping the Middle East.

Before arriving, I had talked to Tom Caruthers, from an influential Washington think-tank, about the risk of a new civil war in Lebanon.

‘The US shouldn’t be in a position of fomenting civil conflict in another country,’ he said, ‘ but, at the same time, Lebanon can’t be condemned to a situation of semi-occupation by Syria. There is a risk, but this is a risk-taking administration – particularly in the Middle East.’

Except, it seems, the Lebanese might have learnt from the last time around.

One of the key players wields influence from a castle high in the Chouf mountains outside Beirut. He is the leader of a small and close-knit sect known as the Druze. Its fighters were deployed as far back as the 13th Century to protect the coastline against Christian crusaders.

The castle is a museum of Soviet Cold War memorabilia. A wall-size portrait of Lenin stares down at Yasser Arafat, there are rows of Soviet medals, a military uniform on a tailor’s dummy, a huge oil painting of Soviet victory against Hitler; and an artillery range-finder, now a polished ornament standing by the sweeping mountain-view window in the living room.

So, whose side are the Druze on this time?

Not a good question in modern Lebanon, particularly when put to the debonair owner of the castle, Walid Jumblat, in his role as leader of a warrior sect.

‘Don’t ask me about all that religious stuff,’ he said. ‘I’m a secularist and a non-believer.’

‘Were you a communist then?’

‘No never,’ he says. ‘But during the Civil War, the Soviets gave us weapons to defend ourselves against the Christians and scholarships to educate the poor. They were very good to us.’

‘And what about now?’ I asked. ‘The Americans are hailing you as a champion of democracy.’

This time he rolled his eyes.

‘They shouldn’t push Syria too far,’ he says. ‘They have an idea of a regime change in Syria and we oppose that. We don’t want the same experience in Syria as in Iraq.’

Over the next few days, in various interviews, it was clear that a common agreement had emerged among the Lebanese.

‘We won’t take part in any civil war,’ said the austere Mohammed Afif of Hizbollah, an Islamic group which in Cold War days would have been in the Soviet camp and is now in the Syrian and Iranian camps.

‘Christians and Muslims alike won’t allow factions to re-introduce violence,’ said an influential Christian member of parliament, Nassib Lahoud.

When I asked him about US suggestions that a multi-national force should come in to replace the Syrians, he added: ‘No. We have not secured Syrian withdrawal to cede the place to other foreign troops.’

I tried to find Ali Aliwan again to run these thoughts past him, but he wasn’t around for that morning’s game of draughts.

Instead I bumped into Samir Buslan, a tall, elegant man in late middle age with thick grey hair who made a living as a driver and a waiter.

He took me to the roof of his apartment block which looked over old sniping positions. During the civil war, Samir was in a minority because he refused to fight. Now, he thinks he’s in a majority.

‘Ten percent of the people want to fight again,’ he said, ‘and make themselves heroes and make some money. But 90% don’t want to fight. They say there’s been enough suffering for our children and our country.’

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on Threads (Opens in new window) Threads
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on Mastodon (Opens in new window) Mastodon
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Primary Sidebar

For enquiries and further information

To contact Humphrey:
[email protected]

Before sending your email address please read our GDPR Compliance Statement and Privacy Notice to reassure yourself that we are looking after your data responsibly.

More reports

How close are we to a Third World War?

Times Radio discussion with Rod Liddle and Lord Owen. … [Read More...]

Screenshot of Democracy Forum webinar

Climate change: South Asia’s biggest threat?

Imagine waking up to find your home submerged, your crops destroyed, and your community in chaos—all … [Read More...]

‘New norms? The role of the Indo-Pacific in a changing world’

New norms? The role of the Indo-Pacific in a changing world

The Democracy Forum presents a round-table discussion, titled ‘New norms? The role of the … [Read More...]

The Democracy Forum 2024 - Pakistan

Political economy: The genesis of uneven growth in Pakistan

The Democracy Forum presents a round-table discussion, titled: Political economy: The genesis of … [Read More...]

Faultlines in China’s internal economic policies

The Democracy Forum Presents a studio discussion, titled ‘Faultlines in China’s internal economic … [Read More...]

From Our Own Correspondent

The Philippines — How China Plans to Win the Asia-Pacific

3rd March 2017

Taiwan-China – a Flashpoint Once More

19th February 2017

Living on America’s Border with Russia

28th August 2015

World Peace Begins in the Bedroom

5th June 2015

The curse of gold

30th May 2012

The supply chain children

30th January 2012

Experiments in aid

30th January 2011

Joining the club

30th July 2010

Banking nuclear fuel

26th January 2010

The ceremony of port

30th December 2009

Dancing with the devil

30th June 2009

The Contractor’s War

30th March 2009

Sharing your man for Jesus

30th March 2009

A million good workers needed

30th October 2008

Russia’s human weapon

30th September 2008

Cold War bunker

30th August 2008

Smoke-filled rooms and the law

30th June 2008

War scars, a handshake and a beacon

26th June 2008

Make knives not war

30th March 2008

Baghdad banking and real estate boom

30th January 2008

America is our ally

30th November 2007

Russia’s red line over Kosovo

30th October 2007

Big Brother is watching us all

30th September 2007

Small town with a big heart

30th June 2007

The democratic mission

30th May 2007

How Kosovo worked

30th January 2007

Hell escape

30th November 2006

Reporting from Israel

30th August 2006

Peace? With our politicians – never

26th June 2006

Lenin and Mao – One day they’ll get it right

30th May 2006

China in the backyard

30th April 2006

Reporting from Poland

26th February 2006

Addicted to oil

26th February 2006

The boy who lived on a garbage dump

30th December 2005

Republican missionaries in New Mexico

26th November 2005

The American dream

30th July 2005

Haunted by the Ottomans

27th February 2005

Empires and abortion

30th December 2004

The young political elite

30th September 2004

Beer with the Hizbollah

30th July 2004

The patriot act

30th June 2004

An economist in Patagonia

27th April 2004

Someone else in her house

28th February 2004

Big threats, no health care

30th December 2003

Inside India’s nuclear program

30th November 2003

Suicide slum

30th September 2003

The politics of SARS

30th April 2003

The Christian mission

27th February 2003

Blood cocoa

30th May 2002

The war crime pen-pushers

30th January 2002

Triple border terror

30th January 2002

Europe’s apartheid

30th September 2001

The blonde and the dying

30th March 2001

Never to be freed

30th January 2000

One wrong turning

30th May 1999

Footer

Travel & Food Blog

Humphrey’s favourite place in Anchorage, Alaska – Mount Baldy

Taiwan – Old China blends with New Asia

For Winter Sun, Unwind in Dubai

Bhutan – Land of Luxury & Legends

Hong Kong & the Great Outdoors

Search site

Goldster

  • The Goldster Conversations Podcast
  • Goldster Conversations Video Archive

Connect with Humphrey

Join Humphrey’s mailing list

Subscribe

Email Humphrey

For general enquiries and bookings for events:

[email protected] and [email protected]

Copyright © 2008–2025 Humphrey Hawksley · All rights reserved · Site Terms, Cookies and Privacy · GDPR Compliance Statement · Website by LiT Web Studio

  • Contact & Photos
  • Subscribe
Manage Cookie Consent
This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies to assist with navigation and your ability to leave comments, analyse your use of our website, assist with our social media promotional efforts, and provide content from third parties.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Cookie choices
{title} {title} {title}